ghost of tsushima cultural appropriation reddit
[–]Thepsi 12 points13 points14 points 8 months ago (1 child), [–]CITY_F0X 42 points43 points44 points 8 months ago (0 children), The greatest take on anything is America portrayed by Japanese writers/developers like, [–]SeaberryPIe 11 points12 points13 points 8 months ago (0 children), [–]Sputniki 10 points11 points12 points 8 months ago (0 children), [–]Wild_Marker 984 points985 points986 points 8 months ago (110 children), Japan is absolutely A-okay making games with Western protagonists telling Western stories. [–]xAncrathKingx 7 points8 points9 points 5 months ago (1 child). [–][deleted] 175 points176 points177 points 8 months ago (18 children). I’ve stuck to koto when I can, that flute is stupid hard. Wether it's considered good or bad depends on who's taking from which culture, how are they doing it, for which reason and with what consequences. If that’s what you want to do, nothing is stopping you. Cultural appropriation isn't a thing in Japan, they're going to see it for it is, which is a loving tribute to Japanese culture and history, made with care and respect. Dark Souls was a great take on western fantasy by Japanese devs, why is it so weird for a western dev to do the same with Japan? Ghost of Tsushima Theme Music Flute v Performance at E3 2018 Online Rockerz 1,065 views Best Mom Eva … It's also this type of person that Japanese people, in my experience at least (which is very sizeable), feel extremely uncomfortable with. The other comments in the thread at the time were also mostly discussing cultural appropriation as well, so my comment was in response to those people and that discussion, rather than the actual article being linked to about Japanese reviewers liking the game. This is extremely offensive to your Asian-American consumers and blatant cultural appropriation. People are absolute pillocks sometimes. [–]xafimrev2 68 points69 points70 points 8 months ago (6 children), [–]BillyPotion 18 points19 points20 points 8 months ago (2 children). My grandfathers are unironically named Mario and Luigi. On the wide end of the spectrum, you can shoot at … Not that I don’t believe you, but I have a guilty pleasure of reading those type comments and the responses it generates. [–]Mesk_Arak 87 points88 points89 points 8 months ago (1 child). [–]satan00[S] 1 point2 points3 points 5 months ago (0 children), [–]dnekuenNinja 2 points3 points4 points 5 months ago (1 child). Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy. Is it possible to defeat the Mongol siege outside Yarikawa before starting the mission? [–]stanfordlouie 71 points72 points73 points 8 months ago (4 children), [–]UnassumingAnt 22 points23 points24 points 8 months ago (1 child). I mean, the lack of giant enemy crabs in any of the trailers and demos was a pretty good indicator that they weren't trying to be historically accurate. Ghost of Tsushima is probably … An interesting experimente that you can make is to look at very old (100+ years) pictures of places that you usually go. [–]kromem 218 points219 points220 points 8 months ago (31 children). I have, and it got me stuck in a wikipedia rabbit hole reading about kingdoms I had no clue existed in my own Country. And also Another Century's Episode, which is a mecha crossover game that features a lot of different mecha anime a la Super Robot Wars. It's not that hard to imagine what western stuff would look like through a Japanese lense. 6 Dani Jo y Can someone at @sony please explain why you chose NOT to hire a Japanese performer to wear traditional Japanese wardrobe, for a Japanese game? Both play on stereotypes for sure, but in a respectful way that injects the perspective of their respective cultures in an interesting way. So I have a class ssignment where we have to make any sort of mask we want and I was thinking of doing the sakai mask from the game..... but I'm worried it might be cultural appropriation... [–]Esham 12 points13 points14 points 5 months ago (0 children). Exactly true. I plan on playing on hard so I ave to sue the stealth and mechanics to their fullest, hopefully. [–][deleted] 271 points272 points273 points 8 months ago* (10 children). They try to be extra woke because it's Austin. [–]lunglocc9 1 point2 points3 points 5 months ago (0 children), [–]AutoModerator[M] 0 points1 point2 points 5 months ago (0 children). What? Scorsese2002: 12: 2/14 1:33PM: POLL: Nioh vs. Sekiro vs. Ghost of Tsushima : thedarklordx3: 25: 2/21 8:16AM: Sense - A Cyberpunk Ghost … In reality the combat has more depth than AC, but not overly complex either. Fast-forward to 2020, and Ghost of Tsushima is once again being called out for a variety of alleged sins: cultural appropriation, historical or language inaccuracies, glorification of the samurai myth, and a failure to capture the “essence” of Akira Kurosawa’s filmmaking being … From what I understand, most of the talent that founded the company and made its early content is gone. I’m also sure that there are plenty of Japanese developers working at Sucker Punch and it’s honestly kind of racist perspective to think American means white. Taco trucks on every corner , [–]MostlyCRPGs 392 points393 points394 points 8 months ago (66 children). I wasn’t even aware that it was controversial for a western studio to make... any game outside of the west? Afro-Samurai, Otoyomegatari, numerous titles that incorporate Chinese folklore or mysticism, event stuff like Fullmetal Alchemist that borrows heavily from western culture for its setting. The Japanese love seeing people interested in their culture. For Ghost of Tsushima on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "The combat". i dont think anyone is upset about it, in this case. Let me explain: That man is one of the … The Wu-Tang Clan was picked by the Asians during the racial drafts of '04 and there hasn't any trade offs, so they don't count. Trying to put myself in their shoes, I imagined a Japanese team making a game historically based in the wild west, or a game set during the American revolution (for each scenario I had to ignore the existence of Red Dead and Assassin's Creed 3), and I thought to myself, that would be pretty damn cool. [–]Flipiwipy 20 points21 points22 points 8 months ago (2 children). I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. It's always people trying to White Knight for another culture or ethnicity that is supposedly offended but most likely doesn't actually care. Also lack of freedom of expresssion in China. Asian people loved it as she looked great in it and was also showcasing how nice Asian outfits are. of 4; Next ; Last ; More topics from this board... Next game? First off, the demographics of that studio should not matter. [–]th30be 15 points16 points17 points 8 months ago (0 children). As one of the last surviving samurai, you rise from the ashes and move beyond your traditions to forge a new way of fighting—the way of the Ghost—as you wage an unconventional war for the freedom of Japan. [–]Hieillua 238 points239 points240 points 8 months ago (50 children). While others say that you have to focus and play well or get wrecked. For more information, see the self-promotion on reddit FAQ. Sucker punch has been pretty upfront that the game is nowhere close to being historically (or even culturally) accurate. It implies that the author wanted to complain about cultural appropriation but didn't get to. [–]versattes 168 points169 points170 points 8 months ago (4 children). [–]NuPNua 65 points66 points67 points 8 months ago (6 children). it's fucking great. Japan, Germany and Mexico are basically exempt from the whole cultural appropriation thing. That was the shakuhachi player, right? © 2021 reddit inc. All rights reserved. That's basically like someone being named Michael and John. Cultural appropriation is a morally neutral term. [–]sheslikebutter 68 points69 points70 points 8 months ago (24 children). There was a picture of a little Caucasian girl (can’t have been older than maybe five or six) wearing a kimono and geisha makeup and a bunch of “white saviors” chimed in to scream about it only to have actual Japanese-Americans and eventually Japanese citizens say they loved it. Do they have any evidence, that the studio is even mostly white. [–]dark_eboreus 120 points121 points122 points 8 months ago (5 children), and also armored core, which shares a lot of gameplay themes, [–]Sulphur99 27 points28 points29 points 8 months ago (0 children). [–]DextrosKnight 33 points34 points35 points 8 months ago (1 child). Also I'm pretty sure the Japanese had fire bending powers in reality until capitulation at the end of WWII. I love me some AC. With the overwhelming might of the enemy against him, the samurai must embrace a different way of warfare, in order to take his revenge, and drive the invaders back. [–]ObscureQuotation 323 points324 points325 points 8 months ago (24 children). ", [–]joetothejack 9 points10 points11 points 8 months ago (2 children). Nothing wrong with respectfully wearing a cultures clothing or eat their food or even make it. What do you think of the other 2 Stances in Ghost of Tsushima? Follow Reddiquette For real though, Swery is an endearing nut, I absolutely love his games. [–][deleted] 1 point2 points3 points 5 months ago (0 children). Yeah Japan is a pretty cool country but they still haven't come to terms with how many fucked up things they did before and during WWII. As one of the last surviving samurai, you rise from the ashes and move beyond your traditions to forge a new way of fighting—the way of the Ghost—as you wage an unconventional war for the freedom of Japan. The roosterteeth people have gotten so annoying the last couple years. And it's not even assassins creed. While not strictly the same my favourite of these is the girl who gets accused of cultural appropriation for a kimono who responds with a picture of her Japanese passport. Author suffers from the white saviour complex, it seems. I bet that same person loves Metal Gear Solid, a Japanese made game not only set in America but also a critique of American warfare and politics. [–]AY_YO_WHOA 101 points102 points103 points 8 months ago (28 children), [–]TSpitty 79 points80 points81 points 8 months ago (25 children). [–]IfinallyhaveaReddit 38 points39 points40 points 8 months ago (3 children), Do you have a source for this? The charge of cultural appropriation is generally only relevant when the offending party is going out of their way to belittle, demean, diminish the significance of, or otherwise bastardize a cultural artifact from a group of people who are already having a tough go. Hey satan00! and join one of thousands of communities. Such stupid bullshit. [–]Merksman72 115 points116 points117 points 8 months ago (24 children). Some people that study Japanese culture are discrediting Sucker Punch’s … [–][deleted] 69 points70 points71 points 8 months ago (0 children), [–]Qorhat 12 points13 points14 points 8 months ago (4 children). [–]snorlz 20 points21 points22 points 8 months ago (1 child), actually the James Cameron one uses some iconic imagery from China as pandora- namely from Zhangjiajie - so chinese people also really identify with that part of it, [–]patorico78 113 points114 points115 points 8 months ago (20 children). I'm reading all sorts of mixed stuff about combat. I don't how anyone could see that as anything other than respect and admiration. There are miles upon miles between that and what you're fixing to do. Let me know! Just do you, if your intentions are pure peeps have no right to bitch about cultural appropiation. The performance, however, was called out as 'blatant cultural appropriation.' Cultural appropriation isn't a thing in Japan, they're going to see it for it is, which is a loving tribute to Japanese culture and history, made with care and respect. [–][deleted] 85 points86 points87 points 8 months ago (21 children). Ghost of Tsushima takes place in 1274 of the Mongol Invasion of Feudal Japan. [–]JJMcGee83 9 points10 points11 points 8 months ago (0 children), [–]Bhu124 7 points8 points9 points 8 months ago (1 child), [–]JJMcGee83 10 points11 points12 points 8 months ago (0 children), [–]vooglie 6 points7 points8 points 8 months ago (0 children), There wasn't enough rural/urban India is my only complaint, [–]Matasa89 9 points10 points11 points 8 months ago (0 children). I think you're fine. [–]NonaSuomi282 31 points32 points33 points 8 months ago (2 children), [–]voltar 43 points44 points45 points 8 months ago (2 children). My interest in the actual assassins creed games has become non existent, [–]Maxplatypus 155 points156 points157 points 8 months ago (17 children), I dont think its pretty shocking japanese people would enjoy a romanticized verison of japan. If you want to promote without participating in the community, purchase an ad. [–]GoddamnKeyserSoze 49 points50 points51 points 8 months ago (9 children), Assassin's Creed isn't really about assassins anymore, is it? It does look like Oni mask which is Japanese demon (someone correct me if im wrong), but it should be ok, [–]lalulunaluna 2 points3 points4 points 5 months ago (3 children). Of course not. Hope the project turns out well! The only thing that would offend them is portraying the Imperial House. Go wild. [–]DrGhostly 66 points67 points68 points 8 months ago (9 children). As if them liking it is a surprise. It don’t make no sense. Aug 15, 2020 #325 Spehornoob said: Don't get me wrong, I love the power fantasy too. Don't get me wrong, I love the power fantasy too. Rendered by PID 11287 on r2-app-087012c704589f488 at 2021-03-15 01:19:38.210905+00:00 running 1ebdfbe country code: US. Plus the people behind the game were hugely inspired by Kurosawa films, one of the most influential Japanese directors. I am Japanese. [–]ZaHiro86 160 points161 points162 points 8 months ago (34 children). It was so full of itself that i couldnt read it all, [–]Narishma 5 points6 points7 points 8 months ago (0 children). Read our guidelines for more information! [–]Deceptichum 188 points189 points190 points 8 months ago (5 children). The collector's edition of this game came with a decorative mask. If you acknowledge the real history and significance of these kinds of masks to Japanese people, it helps shield you from criticisms that may arise as a result of people thinking that you’re trying to make a joke of it. Makes me think of the "try on a kimono" nontroversy where a bunch of asian-americans (many of them not of Japanese descent) were complaining that it aproppriates Japanese culture, but when it got plastered all over the news here the general reaction was "why would we be offended? It took this long to get an assassins creed in Japan. [–]Try_Another_Please 191 points192 points193 points 8 months ago (7 children). When we grow up in the same environment and culture through all of our lives, we tend to appreciate it less because it becomes something common to us. Don't forget to leave a comment, like the video and subscribe to the channel! Especially since the topic was about China, my brain was predisposed to believe they meant the Avatar that takes massive amounts of inspiration from Chinese culture, and not the other one. The reality, there was barely any discussion about this, although I have seen that it has rocked the boat in China where there is a contingent who dont like being cast as the baddies. [–]flaccomcorangy 141 points142 points143 points 8 months ago (7 children). i, for one, fucking love how absolutely overboard Japan goes when portraying American culture. Yeah I remembered this; it happened here in MFA Boston. And how we would never tolerate someone abusing cable cars, the symbol of San Francisco. Ghost of Tsushima's combat is horrendous, sorry; Topic Archived; Page . On the other hand, Japanese right wingers thought the Asian American (non-Japanese) protestors were playing some 4D chess to make Japanese people look bad... [–]ZaHiro86 41 points42 points43 points 8 months ago (7 children). [–]johntheboombaptist 21 points22 points23 points 8 months ago (0 children). [–]jeperty 248 points249 points250 points 8 months ago (42 children), Back when this first got announced at E3, couple of guys from Roosterteeth were up in arms about the game and its presentation, claiming it to be cultural appropriation. Shortly after the presentation was over a woman went on twitter and claimed that the Sony committed cultural appropriation by having a non Japanese man preform on the Shakuhachi flute, for the Ghost of Tsushima reveal, while wearing traditional Japanese wardrobe for the reveal of a Japanese game. This. [–]Betancorea 48 points49 points50 points 8 months ago (3 children). You don't have to imagine it. [–]kareem43110 209 points210 points211 points 8 months ago (49 children), Fuck I’m so hype for this game. A handful of snowflakes complained about cultural appropriation so another group of snowflakes complained about the snowflakes, the rest of the population got on with their day. Not remotely appropriation. [–]acosmichippo 465 points466 points467 points 8 months ago (25 children). I imagine the people at sucker punch are rolling their eyes while reading this review. They clearly did research and respected the culture. [–]1stRateMadness 1 point2 points3 points 5 months ago (1 child). People are trying to cancel Sebastian Stan, No content primarily for humor or entertainment, No personal attacks, witch hunts, bigotry, or inflammatory language, No off-topic or low-effort content or comments. Eg. [–]Firvulag 127 points128 points129 points 8 months ago* (13 children). [–]huxtiblejones 111 points112 points113 points 8 months ago (5 children). Miles the anime writer? I know a couple of Italians, and without exception, they always jump headfirst into floating bricks. Posting unmarked spoilers will result in removal and warning, and posting spoilers with malicious intent will result in a ban. An ambitious, open-world action-adventure game set in 13th century Japan, it’s the last major release to come out exclusively on the PS4 console. Everything in that video was spot on accurate. Don't forget that the Japanese also really like giving traditional items as gifts to foreigners because surprise, thats how you spread your culture and teach others about it. As an Indian, I love it when I see any Indian culture in video games. I remember explaining this to my wife and she just stared at me, incredulous. I'm not Japanese. Do you think maybe it's just that this is a bad platform for discussion? He was also named after an American, John Kirby. My host family saw me eyeing some yukata while they were showing me around Kyoto, bought me one as a gift, and straight up said I look good in it. Eg. [–]nybbas 72 points73 points74 points 8 months ago (18 children). A western team making a game about Japanese history and culture. If you want to be safe, just make it clear that your mask’s design was influenced by this specific video game which in turn took inspiration from the real-world examples of Japan. I’ve tried to learn it repeatedly, thinking “I played flute and clarinet in school, I should be able to figure this out!” Haha. Sometimes we do appreciate less our culture and our roots because it's ours. For me, cultural appropriation happens when someone either profits from a culture that is not their own to the detriment of members of that culture, or uses a culture in a denigrating way. We like seeing foreigners in Kimono. RE7 or Ghost of Tsushima: SCCAN85: 2: 2/13 9:25PM: How has there been no price drop for Ghost of Tsushima yet? The point that I think it is insulting is when people want to make or do Japanese things or Japanese inspired things and do so little research that its obvious they watched a few episodes of Avatar and Naruto and thought that must be Japan. Western devs, please take note. They're still involved in the work they were doing when they started, the other content is just done by other people. Ghost of Tsushima – Best Ghost Weapons, Stance upgrades, and Techniques By James Billcliffe, Saturday, 25 July 2020 10:40 GMT Share on: Facebook Twitter Reddit So the Cleveland Indians "Chief Wahoo" logo is a combination of both those things. It's fascinating and makes you appreciate more your city because you start to look at it with different lens. Fucking love samurai champloo. I watched Castle in the Sky not too long ago and I immediately recognised the buildings and architecture of The Slag Ravine. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy. Ninjas ffs. People are trying to cancel Sebastian Stan now, because his girlfriend wore a kimono at a costume-party 2 years ago. But if an American showed intrest in my culture I'd be honoured. Yeah, wtf, does he think it'd be ok if black people made this game? French Canadian take on Vikings. [–]itsdrcats 19 points20 points21 points 8 months ago (1 child), Which the guy in the 5500 word review was basically saying. I always found the American concept of cultural appropiation weird. Those people are all still there, they're just not running the "new" content they put out. [–]wimpymist 33 points34 points35 points 8 months ago (2 children). ‘Japanese assassins creed’? As a black kid that ate up almost everything Toonami could throw at me, Afro-Samurai was the shit. That's how I see it. Kind of similar to this - Kung Fu Panda was beloved in China, with Chinese critics asking why a foreign film was better at showing their country's beauty than domestic films. [–]Cpt_Tsundere_Sharks 606 points607 points608 points 8 months ago (34 children), I had a moment of genuine confusion because I thought you were talking about Avatar: The Last Airbender, not James Cameron's Avatar. [–]TyrannRedeagle 462 points463 points464 points 8 months ago (27 children), [–]JohnnyGuitarFNV 108 points109 points110 points 8 months ago (2 children), [–]versatilevalkyrie 50 points51 points52 points 8 months ago (1 child), [–]APiousCultist 266 points267 points268 points 8 months ago (6 children). [–]th30be 7 points8 points9 points 8 months ago (1 child). Honestly I legit think they're avoiding the country. Also, Japan is absolutely A-okay making games with Western protagonists telling Western stories (Metal gear solid as a massive and obvious example). There were several larger negatives in their summary. [–]Dawnspark 18 points19 points20 points 8 months ago (0 children). [–]fe-and-wine 6 points7 points8 points 8 months ago (0 children), I'm pretty sure this is why every Assassin's Creed game for the last decade or so begin with the text 'This game is the product of a multicultural team with diverse backgrounds, opinions, etc etc', [–]GonvVasq 55 points56 points57 points 8 months ago (4 children), [–]smoothjazz666 59 points60 points61 points 8 months ago (3 children). [–]nvmvoidrays 28 points29 points30 points 8 months ago (2 children). The latest victim of this is Sony’s exclusive Ghost of Tsushima. [–]Defilus 5 points6 points7 points 8 months ago (2 children), It's starting to sink in that we'll never get an AC6. They probably said nothing about that of any Assassin's Creed games either even though they've been doing the same idea for years. It has become an action RPG with solid stealth mechanics, [–]Valtekken 56 points57 points58 points 8 months ago (0 children), Wouldn't call the stealth mechanics solid when you can't even assassinate enemies if they have a higher level than yours, but other than that yes, [–]kareem43110 58 points59 points60 points 8 months ago (2 children), Honestly feel this. I think itsa mazing! Kojima's been riffing on American Idealism for years. People are saying that, due to GoT being made by a western studio, it's "cultural appropriation". Same. [–]Zakika 6 points7 points8 points 8 months ago (0 children). yuoke. Those countries absolutely love seeing people getting into their culture. and when they showed the long-requested Indian map in the Overwatch 2 trailer. Are you serious? A growing power entering the industrial age, declaring war on its neighbours and invading a nation famed for its big wall. [–]invaderark12 13 points14 points15 points 8 months ago (1 child). [–]presidentofjackshit 9 points10 points11 points 8 months ago (0 children), [–]Dantai 66 points67 points68 points 8 months ago (3 children). You're probably fine if you take a moment to learn about the history of the men-yoroi and don't do anything inappropriate with the mask.