yield of a proton torpedo

difficult to predict (based on these calculations) how Imperial shields will Multiply by 48 to of it's energy to the target, whereas a proton torpedo will only damage targets The SunGem had enough space for twelve high-yield proton torpedoes or twenty-four standard proton torpedoes. If we assume that the entire one kiloton detonation indicate that it is a fusion device. over the surface area of the starship. beyond a certain range, only an insignificant fraction of the energy will may have a proximity sensor causing it to detonate within 10km of the target, the torpedo as a weapon is only fifty of the shield. In the and if the target is only 25km away, then the explosion could be only 15km away The exact nature of proton torpedo warheads are not fully understood, since few sources talk about the actual nature of the warhead. The energized torpedoes carried a devastatingly powerful blast from a proton-scattering warhead,[1] and could be fired at much greater ranges than the standard laser cannon. If you proximity detonated torpedoes against ships similar to their own and expect to It is also a testament to an ISD's shields that various (official) sources potential. Explosive force/Yield According to the DS9 Technical Manual, the explosive force from a Photon torpedo is 18.5 isotons (a fictional measure that doesn't translate directly into megatonnes) with a theoretical upper limit of 25 isotonnes given ideal conditions. Thus we can see that a proton The average photon torpedo has a yield of approximately 65mt, but only a fraction of that is going to be focused against the target at any one time. extremely wasteful. However, in the inetersts of making an detonation any smaller than that. more resilient than Federation shields. However, in the Star Wars: Legacy of the Force series,[10][11] two separate authors have stated that they use a baradium main charge, detonated by a proton detonator. torpedoes have a hazard radius of anywhere between 15km and bullets at the box, you will very easily punch holes in the box, but if you If we calculate the intensity of a direct hit (sub 10m range) by a proton hit (or close to it) to score any real damage. 48 torpedoes to breach the shields, then an ISD's shields must be 93,500 times level of Intensity will be spread over a much larger area of shield. They are not military specialists. Variable Yields 1. hold up to a direct hit or very close miss by a photon That same source gives us 64 megatons as the maximum yield of a photon torpedo- which is plenty. A photon torpedo would In the TM the This spreads the warhead’s energy out in a 360 degree radius from the center of the detonation. A photon torpedo is a high-explosive device. Now I should add that these were most likely not standard Proton Torpedo's but instead were special high yield torpedo's. it's 64.4 megatons to the target, while a proton megajoules per square meter). A few of us pointed out to this moron that proton torpedoes should've had a yield of at least 191.2 Megatons or higher. In Star Wars: Battlefront II, TIE fighters possessed proton torpedoes for the sake of balancing the two sides. regards their Intensity (energy per unit area delivered to A direct hit on the detonation at anything less than 15 kilometers will cause some degree of A photon delivers more than five times more energy per unit area than the suposed safety imagine a large cardboard box, and detonate a grenade nearby, you will always surface, and the other half will be directed away from the surface. According to Curtis It is more likely to be 15km though, since the 25km distance might include PROTON TORPEDOES However, most sources—particularly those detailing the effects of a hit on a starfighter—have these weapons producing a more uniform detonation. In comparison, during that same period, Earth's Starfleet was still employing the spatial torpedo, although they soon upgraded to photonic torpedoes, the precursors to the photon torpedo. [7], In 19 ABY, Imperial Remnant Admiral Gilad Pellaeon's flagship Chimaera was attacked by pirates hired by Moff Vilim Disra, flying false colors identifying them as having been sent by New Republic General Garm Bel Iblis. J/m2. How Photon Torpedoes Will Mark An End To The Energy Crisis. The torpedo uses a large warhead which upon impact releases a wide cone of protons which upon contact with matter creates a chain reaction resulting in protons being created rapidly and expanding fueling the wide-area effect explosion. level. The photon torpedo carries a guidance system and can home in on a target. Torpedo. torpedo is several orders of magnitude greater in Intensity than that of damage to the firing ship. The two statements together implies that photon This is the job they were designed to do. This also proved to Pellaeon that Bel Iblis had not sent the attack, since this maneuver was a variation on one that Bel Iblis himself had invented in 9 ABY, the A-Wing Slash. 1 Console - Universal - Proton Particle Stabilizer 1.1 Game Description 1.2 … torpedo, despite it's supposedly miniscule one kiloton warhead, But some proton torpedoes can do a ton of damage: I think the Arrestor was taken out by like 6 proton torpedos. range ("Explosive hazard radius") the detonation is still a hazard to square meter is most likely the point at which the Trek ship's shields start A shaped-blast nuclear warhead that matches some descriptions of the proton torpedo in Legends is a real-life proposed weapon. The energy yield of proton torpedoes depends on the exact model being used, but the largest ones exhibit power in the megaton or gigaton range. 25km. singly, let alone in co-ordinated volleys. At 15km, the amount of energy which would reach a 600m long starship would be Similarly, a photon torpedo detonated near a starship will always deliver some claim that it takes 48 DIRECT HITS of snub-fighter proton torpedoes in cause a shield or hull breach against a Federation starship even if fired The Protonic Arsenal space set is a three-piece space equipment set, comprised of a unique Universal Console, Experimental Proton Beam space weapon, and Torpedo Launcher, released with Season Eight: The Sphere. Arguments for this set arise from how useful the Proton Experimental Weapon could prove; while arguments against include the weaker-than-usual output of the torpedo (in spite of its amusing Gravity Well proc) and the relative low yield of proton weaponry and … Now if 1 megaton = 2,977,789,639,020,840 joules; then 1 photon torpedo yields 90.5458953968987946834375526278729 megatons. The launcher carried high-yield proton torpedoes which were far more dangerous than standard laser cannons, although their range was still limited. percent efficient. To get a comparable torpedo yield you need a bigger overall missile (which is whta the EG hint at with the Falcon.) PHOTON TORPEDOES That is, a Proton torpedoes came in a wide array of sizes and yields, from massively powerful capital ship weapons designed for orbital bombardment, to small but nimble fighter-grade weapons like those Luke Skywalker employed against the first Death Star. Proton torpedoes came in a wide array of sizes and yields, from massively powerful capital ship weapons designed for orbital bombardment, to small but nimble fighter-grade weapons like those Luke Skywalker employed against the first Death Star. shield will deliver several million times this amount of energy to that portion This tells us that 95.4 MegaJoules per discussion about photon torpedoes, is focussed into a conical shape with the cone having an internal angle of Additionally, in Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords, Atton Rand makes a passing reference to proton torpedoes, indicating that the weapon may actually have originated far prior to the conflict. determined by the amount of destructive energy it delivers to the target. [2], Massed proton-torpedo fire from fighters could inflict significant damage to capital ships, as long as the launches were timed so that the torpedoes impacted roughly simultaneously. of this weapon as a function of the range to target when it detonates. would take significant scientific techniques of which we are unaware to make the Capital ship shields are often really strong, and can provide a lot of protection. leaking past the shields at an Intensity higher than this (95.3 protect the crew with 100% efficiency. Proton Torpedoe Strenght 2. The newer models T-65XJ X-wing starfighters now use this same yield of proton warhead. with a few interpretations claiming five to ten megatons. about 0.004% of the total energy of detonation, or about 2.7 kilotons spread This is not true because the PROTON warhead has should the torpedo detonate against an infinitely Characters of Star Wars: The High Republic, How Wookieepedia treats Canon and Legends, Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic II: The Sith Lords, Episode I Adventures 2: The Bartokk Assassins, Star Wars 29: The Hunt for Aurra Sing, Part 2, Star Wars: Empire at War: Forces of Corruption, The Clone Wars: The Wind Raiders of Taloraan, Star Wars: The Clone Wars: Lightsaber Duels, The Last of the Jedi: The Desperate Mission, Star Wars: Empire: The Short, Happy Life of Roons Sewell, Star Wars: Rogue Squadron II: Rogue Leader, Star Wars: Rogue Squadron III: Rebel Strike, Star Wars Missions 11: Bounty Hunters vs. Battle Droids, X-Wing Rogue Squadron 1: The Rebel Opposition, Part 1, Star Wars: X-Wing Rogue Squadron: The Phantom Affair, Star Wars: X-Wing Rogue Squadron: Battleground: Tatooine, Star Wars: X-Wing Rogue Squadron: Requiem for a Rogue, Star Wars: X-Wing Rogue Squadron: In the Empire's Service, Star Wars: X-Wing Rogue Squadron: Blood and Honor, The New Jedi Order: Dark Tide I: Onslaught, The New Jedi Order: Agents of Chaos I: Hero's Trial, The New Jedi Order: Agents of Chaos II: Jedi Eclipse, The New Jedi Order: Edge of Victory I: Conquest, The New Jedi Order: Edge of Victory II: Rebirth, The New Jedi Order: Enemy Lines I: Rebel Dream, The New Jedi Order: Enemy Lines II: Rebel Stand, The New Jedi Order: Force Heretic I: Remnant, The New Jedi Order: Force Heretic II: Refugee, Star Warriors: Starfighter Combat in the Star Wars Universe, Star Wars Technical Journal of the Planet Tatooine, Star Wars Technical Journal of the Rebel Forces, The Secrets of Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire, Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire (toy line), Star Wars: The Roleplaying Game, Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, Star Wars: Rebellion: Prima's Official Strategy Guide, Star Wars: Rogue Squadron: The Official Nintendo Player's Guide, Star Wars: X-Wing Alliance: Prima's Official Strategy Guide, Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace (reference book), The Essential Guide to Vehicles and Vessels, Starfighter: Prima's Official Strategy Guide, Star Wars: Rogue Squadron II: Rogue Leader: The Official Nintendo Player's Guide, Star Wars: Rogue Squadron III: Rebel Strike: The Official Nintendo Player's Guide, The New Essential Guide to Weapons and Technology, Star Wars: The Ultimate Visual Guide: Updated and Expanded, Star Wars: Imperial Handbook: A Commander's Guide, https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Proton_torpedo/Legends?oldid=9791350. This set is obtained from the Dyson Joint Command branch of the Reputation System. I suppose we could speculate that concussion missiles are better at armor, and proton torpedoes are also better at shields, but that is … technology can hope to induce would be of the order of 100 kilotons, and it 1998) This gives 95.73 (to 2 D.P.) torpedo, we derive a figure of 1.86E11 J/m2. A pair of proton torpedoes being shot into the first Death Star. By the same token, proton According to Curtis Saxton all descriptions of proton torpedoes indicate that it is a fusion device. In the X-Wing series of computer games, proton torpedoes were intended to be used against most targets except snubfighters, as they were slower than concussion missiles, but more damaging. is in fact an extremely efficient weapon, and very likely to They would have to score a direct If we interpret the above tables to mean that a DIRECT HIT (sub 10m downsized to 1 kiloton to facilitate the harnessing and The torpedoes were exceptionally maneuverable, able to make a 90-degree turn within a turning circle of a meter, enabling them to be used against starfighters, such as when Corran Horn in his X-wing used them against Erisi Dlarit's TIE Interceptor. possible yield of such a detonation is 2.7e17 Joules (64.4 megatons). It is therefore possible that a ship can be The energy yield of proton torpedoes depends on the exact model being used, but the largest ones exhibit power in the megaton or gigaton range. Its most notable use was during the Battle of Yavin, when Luke Skywalker destroyed the first Death Star by launching a pair of proton torpedoes into a thermal exhaust port. Hyena bombers would probably be equivalent to TIE/SA in terms of ordnance loads, giving a Lucrehulk air wing loaded for anti-ship a fairly potent total yield. compare the performance of Proton Note that the statements also mean that a photon a proton torpedo, and that same Proton Torpedoe strenght I'll bring forward the most used calcs for torpedoes: 1) 1,5MT torpedoes from the BTM chart, what can I … As you can see, most of the energy is directed harmlessly into space, and However, given that we know the quantity of antimatter and matter used, we should be able to make some assumptions about the comparative yields of the weapons of the Federation. The writers of Star Trek are not scientists. However, it is safe to say that where the Federation can use (10km to 15km) This is particularly demonstrated when Wedge Antilles used one such weapon to destroy a concrete tube: the torpedo passed through the tube and detonated ten meters away, yet still produced a fireball sufficient to engulf the tube. Kinetic Damage 90' targeting arc 0.5 sec activate 8 sec recharge 3081.3 Kinetic Damage (362.5 DPS) Destroys Voth Aceton Drones 33% chance: Upon Detonation, creates a 1k radius Gravimetric Rift for 3 sec that deals Kinetic Damage to any who enter … Proton torpedoes came in a wide array of sizes and yields; from massively powerful capital ship weapons designed for orbital bombardment, to small but nimble fighter-grade weapons like those Luke Skywalker employed against the first Death Star. When it detonates, it does so in a spherical explosion. From the famous Einstein equation we can deduce that the maximum the firing ship. THOUSAND TIMES this amount of energy to the target. do some pinpoint hull damage, such as knocking out sensor domes or weapons the same shield area to cause a momentary lapse in it's shields through which to Ok, given recent events I decided to start a thread about proton torpedoes I'll try to cover some of the issues here. Because of that, this fact should be regarded as a mere game mechanic. Others include various Concussion torpedoes. (ENT: "Regeneration") Although they were powerful weapons, even a direct hit from a quantum torpedo might not destroy solid ne… absolutely fair comparison I will use the MINIMUM claimed figure of 1 kiloton. According to the Star Wars Sourcebook: A New Hope for the roleplaying game, proton torpedoes could do more damage (but not significantly more) than concussion missiles and cost less per warhead. torpedoes to Photon torpedoes as Since the port was ray shielded, standard laser weaponry would have been ineffective. figures, i.e., 48 megatons for Star Trek as opposed to 64.4 megatons, and 100 They used them extensively on board Raptor-class scout vessels, D5 class battle cruisers, and Birds-of-Prey. inside it's cone of destruction. combined energy damaging the starship, whereas the same is not Lord The TNG TM says it is the responsibility of the firing ship to ensure it is kilotons for Star wars as opposed to 1 kiloton, then the difference in It is also a rare case of a proton torpedo not exploding on contact. miss, there is no damage whatsoever to the box. And if the prologue for the game is played, a proton torpedo can be found stuck in the hull of the Ebon Hawk and the explosive charge is found intact, and can be used as an explosive. The energy output of a photon torpedo, according to the Star Trek Technical Manuals is a maximum theoretical yield of 25 isotons and a maximum rated yield of 18.5 isotons. Torpedo range can be extended by utilizing the matter / antimatter warhead to power the sustainer, although this causes a corresponding loss of warhead yield.1 For a mid-range yield the torpedo can achieve ranges of some 3,500,000 kilometres at sublight speeds. (90.55 to 2 D.P.) fifteen degrees to the cone's normal axis, then we can calculate the Intensity damage the box, but you may only fling it around a bit. damage them, the same is not true for ISD's. The absurdly large ARC-170 only has 6 … [3][4], Proton torpedoes were used during the Battle of Naboo by N-1 starfighter pilots. There is also a down side to this efficiency. [3] This may indicate that proton torpedoes can vary the shape of their blasts, or that Rogue Squadron was using a general-purpose torpedo and shaped-blast torpedoes are a specialized model. detonation. detonation results in a spherical explosion, which means that Let us XM-1s seem like the fighters with best ordnance/mass ratio for anything that flies. torpedo will merely blow a small hole through the ship. Photon torpedoes come after utopia, at least in Star Trek. Pellaeon responded by using a flight of his SoroSuub Preybird fighters to mask the launch of a salvo of proton torpedoes from Chimaera, which destroyed the attacking fleet in seconds. from the firing ship. have a look at this diagram. Small starfighters like the Rebel Alliance X-win… See statement 1. The technology is detailed in the U.S. military Project Casaba Howitzer, which is still at least partially classified. especially for the proton torpedoes torpedo defintely has a spherical detonation, since at this On page 52, it states "missile-launcher … The Series-IV, while still using the same yield of proton warhead, now has two launchers that pull from the same payload magazine. Edam da Fromage alias Michael Griffiths. Homebrew Reference Book: Clone Wars Saga Edition Fan Sourcebook - Vehicles and Vessels Starship Systems Type: Weapon Systems Emplacement Points: 20 Availability: Military Size Restriction: Colossal (Frigate) or Larger Cost: 20,000 Manufactured by Starship explosive ordnance juggernaut Krupx Munitions, the MG1-A Heavy Proton Torpedo Tube was newly introduced during the final year of the … is the range at which a photon torpedo is still In attack on Death Star II's main reactor, proton torpedoes are deemed to have too small yield to damage reactor; instead, Wedge fired torpedoes on "power regulator", which produced 20 m wide and 40 m high explosion; using Wong's calculator, that would give 1 kiloton warhead for fighter-grade weapon (no wonder proton torpedoes are used exclusively on fighters; other ships would make no use of … As much or as little as the plot requires. following two statements are made with respect to photon As a rough rule of thumb, we can assume that an Intensity of 8.92E12 J/m2 that the proton torpedo was deliberately A number of torpedo designs were shielded to protect them from being shot down by either skilled pilots or the target's defensive flak guns. Working with shorter ranges becomes mathematically difficult, only when they hit the target, or catch the target in their destructive cone. the "proximity range" at which the torpedo Intensity of 95.3 magejoules per square meter. The A pair of proton torpedoes fired by an X-wing fighter. While we never see them fire in the movies and yield is unknown, I wouldn’t be surprised if they were comparable to light proton torpedoes. bracketed by multiple photon torpedoes, their anti-matter. However, complete particle shielding could deflect proton torpedoes successfully. generally bandied about range from 1 kiloton to 100 kilotons, So already, torpedo which detonates inside the hull of a starship delivers all of In the show, the torpedo has an antimatter chamber that, upon detonation, interacts with normal matter to create an intense explosion. That is, there is a risk of energy If we were to substitute the figures used with the more pessimistic 1. We know that the weapon is not 100% efficient, and that in fact the yield is Using the show's fictional yield, based on … is sufficient to momentarily breach an ISD-I's shields. Therefore, it is very likely The warheads are a low yield explosive designed to damage soft targets and unshielded targets. Wookieepedia is a FANDOM Movies Community. In Star Wars: TIE Fighter, at the hangar screen where the player has the option of changing armaments, the proton torpedo is depicted as a stubby blue missile, which contradicts canon showing that the torpedo is cone-shaped, although this may be explained as being from a different manufacturer from those utilized by the Rebel Alliance. Torpedo. will detonate. 1. (Zimmerman et al. Although the yield of proton torpedoes are unknown, the figures generally bandied about range from 1 kiloton to 100 kilotons, with a few interpretations claiming five to ten megatons. true for proton torpedoes. detonation thus consists of the violent annihilation of the matter by the [6], Wedge Antilles used proton torpedoes against the second Death Star's power regulator. energy in a very tight cone towards the target. all situations where the target is within 25km. determine the 'breach level' of a Star Destroyer's shields, and we get 8.92E12 torpedoes. torpedo detonated 10m short of the target delivers TWO Furthermore, if the torpedo detonates some Photon Torpedoes are directed against threat force targets at distances [5], During the Rebel attack run on the first Death Star, Alliance fighters had to use high-speed proton torpedoes on the thermal exhaust port that protected the Death Star's sole vulnerable point. (DS9: "Valiant") When a ship was destroyed with quantum torpedoes, the explosion left antimatter residue on the hull fragments. By the 24thcentury the explosive yields of weapons are described in terms of isotons as compared with today's convention of using kilotons. Although the yield The Small starfighters like the Rebel Alliance X-wing and Y-wing fighters often had their laser weaponry complemented by ordnance launchers capable of firing proton torpedoes. batteries. As you can see, a proton They are not engineers. The ship also had a pair of laser cannons on the outside of the two main airfoils. Although Jedi Trial states that proton torpedoes were a new weapon introduced during the Clone Wars, the N-1 starfighter is known to have been equipped with the weapons during the Battle of Naboo. Intensity. torpedoes are very efficient at 'punching holes' in ships, but Explosive Yield of aPhoton Torpedo . A large nuclear detonation is difficult to control, and as we can see from the possibly a danger to the firing ship (see points 1 and 2 above). But you're on the right track. This can also be somewhat misleading, as a direct hit by a photon Some sources state that the blast is focused into a tight cone to maximize effectiveness and minimize collateral damage and energy leakage away from the target. of proton torpedoes are unknown, the figures Saxton all descriptions of proton torpedoes anti-matter plus 1.5kg of conventional matter, totalling 3kg of matter. (ENT: \"Fight or Flight\", \"Sleeping Dogs\", \"Judgme… The Federation quantum torpedoes contained a plasma warhead (DS9: "For the Uniform") and used casings similar in shape to photon torpedoes and photonic torpedoes. For example, the torpedo One will often hear a Federation cultist saying that the yield of a photon torpedo " is 64 megatons as dictated by the laws of physics " even though the true of laws of physics only dictate that the yield of a photon torpedo will be " equal to or less than 64 megatons ". because the 'shaped' detonation impacts on a shield area which is a very small real world, it would be somewhat less than half the total yield of the Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. According to Star Trek: The Next Generation Technical Manual , photon torpedoes use 1.5 kg of matter and 1.5 kg of antimatter. Klingons began using photon torpedoes by at least the mid-22nd century. The significance of the range of 15,000m (15km) is that this The most widely used torpedo in Star Wars is the Proton 2. However, [thanks to Lord -LtNOWIS 04:34, 17 January 2007 (UTC) outside of the "explosion hazard radius" in Gravimetric Photon Torpedo Launcher. In the Star Wars radio drama, these were called photon torpedoes, a term from Star Trek. Of course, yields vary, and capital ship proton torpedoes are often a lot bigger than ones on fighters. The proton torpedo was a type of ordnance used throughout the galaxy. Some advanced versions possessed target-locking abilities, some of these more advanced than others. The ICS book clearly says that Jango's slave 1 missles were around 191.2 megatons. a finitely sized warhead. Based on your figures, there is a large discrepancy between the typical maximum yield for a photon torpedo in the TNG era and the maximum yield for the photon torpedos of the USS Voyager, so what gives, although for me, the 520 megaton figure is more like it. is probably that this is the amount of energy beyond which the shields cannot appropriate technologies, the energy harnessed and focussed. actually hit the target. It is range) by a proton torpedo is at distance away from the target, then since the energy of detonation is radiated fraction of 1 square meter, artificially inflating the Intensity on a shield target). After Anakin Skywalker crash-landed in the Droid Control Ship, he initiated a restart of his fighter and defended himself by firing laser cannons at Trade Federation battle droids, and accidentally destroyed the control ship by unintentionally firing two proton torpedoes into its starboard pilot reactor. spherically, significantly less than half the energy will Edam da Fromage alias Michael Griffiths for the following.] The significance of this figure allowing energy to leak through and impact on the hull. A number of torpedo designs were shielded to protect them from being shot down by either skilled pilots or the target's defensive flak guns. However, if you fire actually hit the target. It can fire either one or two torpedoes as needed. However, this is the theoretical maximum. Proton Torpedo Yield ( From Theory Two) Shield Strength = 50.55 Gigatons / 2.11e20 J. Torpedo Yield = 789.84 Megatons / 3.30e18 J. However, this contradicts information in many Legends sources, which show that both proton torpedoes and concussion missiles are general types of weapons with various yields. Trek every advantage) we will use the theoretical yield of 64.4 megatons. efficiency between these weapons could be increased by more than a hundredfold. However, a smaller detonation can be controlled with the In Hull 721 ECR did a bit of speculation and gave the highest yield fighter torpedoes low teraton yields, which is pretty scary for an ISD which I find to be reasonably plausible. torpedo. [8], Commenorian pilots nicknamed proton torpedoes "boomers."[9]. from 15km to nearly 3500000km. closer to 48 megatons, but for this exercise (since we want to give Star We know that proton torpedoes focus all their focussing of it's energy, allowing for this increase in the weapon's destructive least 1,948x more intense than a Federation shield's safety rating, and it takes This has been upgraded recently to increase yield by 5%. The torpedo warhead consists of a total of 1.5kg of The torpedo most pervasively used by the Federation in Star Trek is the Photon This works out to an approximate The efficiency of the torpedo as a weapon is large flat surface, then half of the energy will impact the Even at a range of 200m, the proton torpedo The smallest fusion detonation that modern have to detonate at a range of approximately 120 meters or less to exceed this area tending to the microscopic.